When a loved one passes away, the process of administering their estate can become complex - especially when multiple individuals believe they should be in charge. Whether due to unclear estate planning documents, conflicting interests, or family disagreements, disputes over estate control can delay probate, drain estate assets, and fracture family relationships. This article breaks down what happens when multiple people want to manage an estate and how you can resolve or prevent these issues.
Contact us by either using the online form or calling us directly at 414-253-8500 for legal assistance.
Understanding Who Has Legal Authority Over an Estate
Before diving into what happens when multiple people want control, it's important to understand how legal authority is granted in estate matters:
Executor (Named in a Will)
If the deceased had a valid will, they likely nominated an executor (also called a personal representative). This person is responsible for:
-
Filing the will with the probate court
-
Managing estate assets
-
Paying debts and taxes
-
Distributing assets to beneficiaries
Administrator (Appointed by the Court)
When there is no will, or the named executor is unavailable or declines, the court appoints an administrator. This person functions similarly to an executor but is selected according to the state's laws of intestate succession.
Common Scenarios That Trigger Conflict
Estate disputes can arise for several reasons when multiple individuals seek control:
1. Multiple People Named as Co-Executors
Some wills name more than one executor, often to avoid favoritism or to ensure fairness. While well-intentioned, this can lead to practical and emotional challenges, including:
-
Disagreements on decision-making
-
Delays in estate administration
-
Unequal participation or contribution
2. No Executor Named or Will Is Contested
If the will is vague or contested, more than one person may petition the probate court to be appointed as administrator. Courts evaluate:
-
Relationship to the deceased
-
Competency and trustworthiness
-
Potential conflicts of interest
-
Criminal history or past misconduct
3. Family Members Disagree on Who Should Serve
Even when one person is clearly named, other family members may challenge the appointment if they believe the person is:
-
Unfit (due to illness, incapacity, or criminal background)
-
Dishonest or financially irresponsible
-
Likely to act against the best interest of the estate
4. Heirs with Equal Standing Seek Appointment
In intestate estates (no will), statutes often prioritize spouses, adult children, or parents. When multiple heirs have equal priority, such as siblings, and can't agree, the court may need to:
-
Appoint a neutral third party
-
Require co-administration
-
Hold a hearing to determine suitability
How Courts Resolve Conflicts Over Estate Control
When more than one person petitions the court, judges often look for the most capable and impartial candidate. Courts may consider:
-
The petitioner's relationship to the decedent
-
Their financial or legal experience
-
Past interactions with other heirs or beneficiaries
-
Willingness to serve impartially
If none of the competing individuals are appropriate, a professional fiduciary, public administrator, or attorney may be appointed to avoid further delays and prevent mismanagement.
Co-Executors: Legal, But Not Always Practical
Though naming multiple executors is legally allowed, co-executors must act jointly, unless the will states otherwise. This means:
-
Both must sign documents
-
Both must agree on all decisions
-
Both are equally liable for mistakes or misconduct
If co-executors cannot agree, the process can grind to a halt - increasing court involvement and estate expenses. In these situations, one co-executor may:
-
Petition the court for sole authority
-
Request that the other be removed for cause
-
Agree to step aside to avoid conflict
Preventing Estate Disputes Through Thoughtful Planning
The best way to avoid these disputes is to proactively address control issues during estate planning. Here's how:
-
Choose a Single, Responsible ExecutorSelect someone who is organized, impartial, and willing to serve. A trusted friend or a neutral professional may be a better option than a conflicted family member.
-
Name a Backup ExecutorIf your chosen executor cannot serve, having an alternate avoids ambiguity and delays.
-
Clearly State Executor PowersIncluding clauses that allow independent administration or waive bond requirements helps simplify the process.
-
Avoid Naming Co-Executors Unless Absolutely NecessaryMultiple executors often introduce unnecessary complications.
-
Discuss the Plan With Your FamilyTransparency can prevent surprises and reduce the risk of conflict after your death.
What to Do If a Dispute Has Already Arisen
If a conflict over estate control is already underway, it's important to act quickly and responsibly to protect the estate and your rights.
1. Consult With an Estate Attorney Immediately
Whether you're the named executor or an heir disputing someone's appointment, legal counsel is critical. An estate lawyer can help:
-
File or oppose petitions in probate court
-
Challenge or defend the validity of a will
-
Request a neutral administrator if needed
-
Ensure compliance with state probate laws
You can contact our office at any time or call 414-253-8500 to speak with an attorney regarding estate disputes.
2. Avoid Self-Dealing or Withholding Information
Even if you believe you're the rightful administrator, avoid taking unilateral actions such as:
-
Withdrawing funds from estate accounts
-
Selling property
-
Denying other heirs access to documents
These actions could result in removal by the court, financial penalties, or civil lawsuits.
3. Seek Mediation Before Litigation
Mediation can help families resolve disagreements without a drawn-out court battle. With the help of a neutral third-party mediator, parties may be able to:
-
Agree on a single administrator
-
Divide tasks among co-administrators
-
Create a timeline for distributing assets
Mediation is often faster, more cost-effective, and less emotionally draining than probate litigation.
Can an Executor Be Removed?
Yes - courts have the authority to remove an executor or administrator under certain conditions. Common reasons include:
-
Failure to perform duties (such as not filing required documents)
-
Mismanagement or theft of estate assets
-
Conflict of interest with beneficiaries
-
Incapacity or illness
-
Fraud or dishonesty
Heirs can file a formal petition asking the court to remove the executor. The court may schedule a hearing and require proof before taking action.
For more on this process, visit our article on how to contest an executor if the person in charge is not fulfilling their duties.
What Happens If No One Can Agree?
If heirs or potential executors cannot reach a consensus, the court may appoint a neutral third party, such as:
-
A professional fiduciary
-
A probate attorney
-
A public administrator
This is often done to prevent further estate depletion and ensure compliance with probate law. While this option adds cost, it can be the most efficient route when conflicts are deep or unresolvable.
Legal Tools That Can Help Prevent Future Disputes
When clients ask how to reduce the risk of family conflict over their estate, we often recommend:
Revocable Living Trusts
Unlike a will, a living trust allows you to appoint a trustee to manage your assets during your lifetime and after your death - with no need for probate. You can also appoint:
-
Successor trustees in case the first choice is unable or unwilling to serve
-
Corporate trustees to maintain neutrality and professionalism
Learn more in our comparison of revocable living trusts vs. wills.
No-Contest Clauses
A no-contest clause discourages disputes by stating that any beneficiary who challenges the will or trust will lose their inheritance. While not enforceable in all situations, these provisions can prevent unnecessary litigation. Explore how they work in our article on no-contest clauses.
Contact an Estate Administration Attorney Today
Whether you're trying to resolve a dispute, challenge an executor, or prevent future family conflict, working with a knowledgeable estate attorney can help you protect your loved one's legacy.
At Heritage Law Office, we assist clients in navigating complex estate matters with professionalism and compassion. If you are facing issues with multiple people wanting control of an estate - or need help creating a clear estate plan - we can help.
Call us at 414-253-8500 or use our online contact form to schedule a consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What happens if there is no will and multiple people want to manage the estate?
If there is no will, the estate is considered intestate, and the probate court will appoint an administrator. When multiple people with equal standing (like adult children) apply, the court evaluates each individual's qualifications and may choose one based on who is best suited. In some cases, the court may appoint co-administrators or a neutral third party if there's significant disagreement.
2. Can co-executors make decisions independently?
In most cases, co-executors must act jointly, meaning they both need to agree and sign off on major decisions such as selling property or distributing assets. If they cannot work together effectively, one can petition the court to resign or request that the other be removed due to conflict or incompetence.
3. How does the court choose between people who both want to be in charge of the estate?
The court considers several factors when deciding between competing petitioners, including:
-
Their relationship to the deceased
-
Trustworthiness and financial responsibility
-
Ability to remain impartial
-
Any history of misconduct or criminal background
The court's goal is to appoint the person most likely to carry out the estate's administration efficiently and fairly.
4. Can a will name more than one executor?
Yes, a will can name co-executors, and many people do this to promote fairness among siblings or family members. However, this can sometimes create delays or conflicts. It's often more efficient to name a single executor and include an alternate in case the first cannot serve.
5. What legal options exist if someone believes the wrong person was appointed executor?
If a beneficiary or heir believes the wrong person was appointed, they can file a formal objection with the probate court. Valid reasons include mismanagement, conflict of interest, fraud, or incapacity. The court will review the objection, hold a hearing if necessary, and may remove the executor or appoint a new one depending on the evidence provided.